Dear Mr Streeting,
We were alarmed by the discussion during the Committee stage of the Terminally Ill Adults (End of Life) Bill about whether hospices may find themselves compelled to provide assisted suicide/dying on their premises or risk losing NHS or other public funding.[1]
We note also that an amendment which sought to insert clarity into the Bill that there would be no obligation on any care home or hospice to provide assisted suicide on their premises was rejected. Additionally, the Minister of State for Care’s comments in relation to that amendment wholly focused on the impact for individuals seeking an assisted death, but made no mention of the negative impact such an obligation would have upon the provision of palliative care or the detrimental effects on providers of such care.
Euthanasia and assisted suicide are contrary to a foundational principle of palliative care which is ‘neither to hasten nor to postpone death’. It contradicts our core function of caring for people until their natural death. The paradigm shift required for staff to assist patients to take their own lives should not be underestimated. Hospices hold to an ethical framework of ‘do no harm’. The vast majority of palliative care doctors would not provide assisted suicide. Many would leave their post if assisted suicide was proposed as part of their services.[2]
Some hospices may be forced to close should they be denied NHS funding because they are unwilling to participate in the provision of assisted suicide.
Our hospices provide expert, community based, specialist palliative care which is world-leading in our sector. We do not want to kill our patients, nor have them fearful that we may do just that. Let us do the job we are trained to do.
We urgently request clarity from the Government that no hospice will be denied public funding because they are unwilling to facilitate assisted suicide on their premises or be placed under a duty to provide such a service.
Yours sincerely,
Consultant in Palliative Medicine, London
[1] Hansard. Public Bill Committee 18 MARCH 2025 Terminally Ill Adults (End of Life) Bill 12
[2] https://apmonline.org/wp-content/uploads/APM-Survey-of-AD-Impact-on-PC-FINAL.pdf
Our duty of care is a group of UK healthcare workers who oppose the intentional killing of patients by assisted suicide or euthanasia.
The campaign is administered by David Randall, a consultant nephrologist working in London, and Gillian Wright, a former palliative care doctor based in Scotland.
It is supported by a wide range of healthcare professionals, and has campaigned during the membership polls run by the Royal College of Physicians, Royal College of General Practitioners and British Medical Association to maintain medical opposition to assisted suicide. We are a campaign that is financed and administered by the Care Not Killing Alliance.
Journalists in England, Wales and Northern Ireland – please contact Alistair Thompson on 07970 162225 – [email protected]
Journalists in Scotland – please contact Tom Hamilton Communications on 07836 603977
Care NOT Killing – Promoting palliative care, opposing euthanasia and assisted suicide
A Limited Company in England and Wales, Company No. 06360578
© CARE NOT KILLING 2021 - All rights reserved