VIDEO – Canada’s Euthanasia Experience – Learning the Lessons

If Scotland legalises assisted suicide, it will fundamentally and irrevocably change the nature of medical practice for ever. What are the lessons Scotland can learn from Canada about assisted suicide and euthanasia before it is too late?

Prof Leonie Herx is the Chair of the Division of Palliative Medicine and an Associate Professor in the Department of Medicine at Queen’s University, Kingston, Ontario. This talk was recorded at the Royal College of Physicians and Surgeons in Glasgow on January 31st, 2023.

 

VIDEO CONTENTS

00:00 – Prof David Galloway – Introduction

09:24 – Prof Leonie Herx – Intro & Outline

10:46 – What is MAiD in Canada?

12:18 – MAiD in contrast to palliative care

15:00 – Progression of Canadian legislation

16:30 – Widening of eligibility – court rulings & ‘progressive’ interpretations

21:23 – 2021 legislative changes

22:24 – Eligibility conditions

24:47 – Initial discourse around legislating

25:39 – MAiD Deaths in Canada

26:50 – Nature of suffering of those requesting MAiD

27:54 – Safeguards

32:07 – Oversight of safeguards

35:03 – Healthcare savings in MAiD

36:16 – Healthcare & Social Care Workers recommending MAiD due to cost of care and perceived poor quality of life

40:12 – MAiD due to lack of access to adequate care, poor living conditions, costs of care and fear of COVID lockdowns

42:04 – MAiD has been rapidly normalized as a standard medical therapy

44:50 – MAiD as a source of organ donations

45:54 – Ongoing conflation of MAiD with palliative care (Budget impacts)

47:10 – Hospice funding removed

48:22 – Same day MAiD

49:33 – Access to palliative care in Canada and in MAiD

50:56 – Impact of MAid on palliative care

53:00 – Impact on medicine – Death as a first line ‘treatment’

55:42 – Suicide prevention vs suicide completion?

57:04 – Impacts on society – Romanticising euthanasia

58:28 – Division and conflict within families

59:42 – Advocating for safety becomes regarded as ‘Anti-MAiD’

60:58 – Conclusions

Footnotes